Vidura Niti · Mastering the Senses
Speak Even When Not Asked
शुभं वा यदि वा पापं द्वेष्यं वा यदि वा प्रियम् । अपृष्टस्तस्य तद्ब्रूयाद्यस्य नेच्छेत्पराभवम् ॥
The blind king Dhritarashtra cannot sleep. His half-brother and minister Vidura has been counselling him through the night, and now the king asks again. “Tell me what a man should do who lies awake and burning. You know dharma and artha.” Dharma is duty and right conduct; artha is wealth and the worldly aims of life. He wants to know what is good for Yudhishthira, eldest of his nephews the Pandavas, and for the Kurus, his own house. Then he admits his fear. “I fear evil and see only evil. Tell me all that Yudhishthira has in mind.” Vidura answers with a rule for every counsellor. “Good or bad, hateful or welcome, a man should say it even unasked to one whose ruin he does not want.” Earlier that night Vidura praised the wise man who does not meddle unasked. This is the exception. When someone you care for is heading for a fall, silence is no courtesy. Chapter 2, verse 4.